Consumers' Research Challenges USF in 6th Circuit Again

Consumers’ Research filed another legal challenge to the FCC’s Universal Service Fund, this time against the Q1 2023 contribution factor, in the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. The group has another challenge in the 6th Circuit against the Q4 2021 contribution factor, plus a case in the 5th Circuit against the Q1 2022 factor, and a challenge in the 11th against the Q4 2022 factor. Oral argument was held in the 5th Circuit case earlier this month (see 2212060070), and the FCC filed a response brief in the 11th Circuit last week (see 2212230007). The latest filing takes a similar tack to Consumers’ Research’s other cases, arguing that the USF contribution factor is an unconstitutional tax because it's imposed by the FCC rather than Congress, and that the FCC has violated the Administrative Procedure Act. The group is likely challenging the contribution factor in the same circuit as an ongoing challenge to provide a backstop if the other 6th Circuit case is dismissed or rejected for narrow procedural reasons, said Benton Institute for Broadband & Society Senior Counselor Andrew Schwartzman, who has filed in support of the FCC in other Consumers’ Research cases. Consumers’ Research didn’t comment. The new case likely won’t be briefed or move forward while the other 6th Circuit one is ongoing, Schwartzman said.